Comparison of Image- and Time-of-Flight-Based Technologies for 3D Reconstruction of Infrastructure

Dai, F and Rashidi, A and Brilakis, I and Vela, P (2012) Comparison of Image- and Time-of-Flight-Based Technologies for 3D Reconstruction of Infrastructure. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management. pp. 929-939.

Abstract

Image-based (i.e., photo/videogrammetry) and time-of-flight-based (i.e., laser scanning) technologies are typically used to collect spatial data of infrastructure. In order to help architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industries make cost-effective decisions in selecting between these two technologies with respect to their settings, this paper makes an attempt to measure the accuracy, quality, time efficiency, and cost of applying image-based and time-of-flight-based technologies to conduct as-built 3D reconstruction of infrastructure. In this paper, a novel comparison method is proposed, and preliminary experiments are conducted. The results reveal that if the accuracy and quality level desired for a particular application is not high (i.e., error < 10 cm, and completeness rate > 80%), image-based technologies constitute a good alternative for time-of-flight-based technologies and significantly reduce the time and cost needed for collecting the data on site.

Actions (login required)